The San Francisco Giants announced on Tuesday that they are picking up the 2026 option on manager Bob Melvin’s contract, ensuring his position with the team—for now. However, the timing of the decision is somewhat awkward.
The team is currently enduring a rough stretch, having just been swept at home by the Miami Marlins and winning only one out of three games in a series against the struggling Chicago White Sox. Adding to the recent woes, the Giants suffered another tough loss last night to the Arizona Diamondbacks, a game in which Melvin was ejected.
SF Giants announce Bob Melvin will be coming back in 2026
Had the announcement come earlier in the season—when the Giants were playing well—or even just a few weeks back when they were competing neck-and-neck with the Dodgers atop the NL West, it might have felt more appropriate. But now, as fan frustration grows, the timing feels off.
The press release included a statement from team president of baseball operations Buster Posey, who said, “Working with Bob every day, we’re lucky to have such a seasoned leader—one of the most respected managers in the game. We believe he’s the right person to keep moving this team forward.”
Melvin appears to have the respect of many players in the clubhouse. His long-standing relationship with Matt Chapman, stemming from their time together in Oakland, is one clear example—Chapman likely welcomes the news.
There’s no doubt Melvin brings an old-school style and isn’t afraid to stand up for his team or challenge calls. However, increased scrutiny has fallen on the Giants’ coaching staff recently. Third base coach Matt Williams has made some high-profile mistakes, and hitting coach Pat Burrell has drawn criticism for the team’s offensive struggles. These issues inevitably reflect on Melvin’s leadership, though Posey clearly still has confidence in him.
That said, circumstances can shift quickly. In recent years, there have been moments when coaches or executives appeared secure—only to be let go soon after. If the Giants’ current slide continues and the season spirals, it’s hard to imagine Melvin returning in 2026.
Still, maybe this vote of confidence from the front office will be the spark the team needs. By acquiring Rafael Devers in a trade, they signaled belief in their roster—even if it hasn’t paid off yet. Now they’re doubling down by backing their manager. Hopefully, that belief is rewarded.
Be the first to comment