The St. Louis Cardinals are in an unexpected spot this season. Rather than being out of playoff contention, they entered Friday tied with the San Francisco Giants and San Diego Padres for the final National League Wild Card position. They’ve exceeded expectations significantly, which has left their trade deadline approach uncertain.
The team has several paths it could take — buying, selling, standing pat, or a combination of both to remain competitive while also giving younger players more opportunities.
One complicating factor is their apparent reluctance to trade closer Ryan Helsley. According to Katie Woo of The Athletic, the Cardinals seem more inclined to hold onto him. Ultimately, how the team performs in July will play a big role in determining Helsley’s future.
Still, regardless of how things play out, moving Helsley now is the smart move. His trade value is high, and the Cardinals should take advantage of that while they can.
Cardinals should trade Ryan Helsley regardless of deadline strategy
The Cardinals made the unexpected decision to keep Ryan Helsley last offseason, attempting to balance short-term competitiveness with developing their younger talent. However, it was yet another example of the organization’s inability to fully commit to a clear direction.
This indecision has kept them stuck in mediocrity for years. Trading Helsley now would be a logical move, as his value remains strong. Though slightly diminished from its offseason peak following his 49-save performance in 2024, he’s still the reigning NL Reliever of the Year.
Contenders looking to bolster their bullpens would likely pay a premium for a closer of Helsley’s caliber. A deal could net the Cardinals top-tier pitching prospects—something their farm system sorely needs, especially with limited healthy arms beyond Michael McGreevy.
If they keep him, they risk losing him in free agency after 2025 for nothing more than a compensatory draft pick. While the team and fans may hope to contend, the Cardinals must begin looking ahead.
Even if they stay in the playoff race, this roster isn’t built to win a World Series in 2025. The focus should shift to laying the groundwork for incoming President of Baseball Operations Chaim Bloom, who needs the freedom to reshape the team without carrying over the indecision of the John Mozeliak era.
Be the first to comment