With the Chicago Cubs missing out on Alex Bregman, speculation has arisen about the possibility of them targeting Nolan Arenado from the St. Louis Cardinals.
However, a trade between these two storied rivals remains highly improbable due to historical animosity, financial considerations, and performance concerns.
The Cubs and Cardinals have one of baseball’s fiercest rivalries, making blockbuster deals between them rare. Neither team wants to be responsible for strengthening the other, especially under the scrutiny of their passionate fanbases.
The optics of St. Louis shedding Arenado’s contract to a division rival or Chicago aiding the Cardinals in reducing payroll would create significant backlash.
St. Louis seems more focused on salary relief than acquiring elite prospects, while the Cubs have been disciplined in their long-term financial commitments despite their willingness to spend for short-term upgrades.
With Arenado still owed a substantial amount over the next three years, his contract doesn’t align with Chicago’s financial strategy.
Beyond the rivalry, Arenado’s production has declined. His offensive numbers have dipped closer to league average, and his once-elite defense has regressed. Given the Cubs’ optimism about Matt Shaw’s development, committing resources to a declining veteran doesn’t fit their long-term plans.
While rumors may continue, the combination of rivalry tensions, Arenado’s contract, and Chicago’s internal development strategy makes such a trade highly unlikely. The Cubs will likely explore other ways to improve their roster without assisting their biggest rival.
Be the first to comment