The Cincinnati Reds have gotten off to a rough start in 2025, beginning the season with a disappointing 3-7 record. It’s not the opening fans envisioned under new manager Terry Francona, but one thing the veteran leader is clearly bringing to the team is a strong sense of accountability — no matter a player’s reputation or track record.
Francona, known for his straightforward approach, has made it clear that playing time must be earned, not given. That philosophy is on full display with his handling of closer Alexis Díaz — a key bullpen piece since 2022, but now temporarily out of the mix.
Díaz is currently rehabbing with Triple-A Louisville as he recovers from injury, but hasn’t yet shown he’s ready to return. After two appearances, Francona told reporters that Díaz still needs time. “Physically, we just didn’t feel he was ready — and I think he agrees,” Francona said. “He’ll pitch a few more times with Louisville to get back in rhythm. He knows that and actually supports the decision.”
Alexis Díaz’s closer role in jeopardy as Reds manager Terry Francona demands results
Although Francona emphasized that the Reds still view Alexis Díaz as their long-term closer, he didn’t shy away from setting expectations: “He needs to be ready to handle that role.” For Cincinnati fans, the honesty is welcome — even if the situation itself is troubling.
Díaz has had a hard time finding his form lately. He struggled throughout spring training, failing to deliver a clean inning, and his rehab appearances have been marred by control issues, with walks continuing to pile up.
Over the weekend, Cincinnati lost three out of four to division rival Milwaukee — a team managing to win games despite a patched-together rotation. If the Brewers can stay competitive with a makeshift staff, the Reds can’t afford to keep digging an early-season hole.
Francona remains firm in his results-driven mindset. At the moment, Díaz hasn’t shown he’s reliable in high-pressure spots. As a result, Francona is sticking with a closer-by-committee approach for now.
It’s a measured decision — one that has seen success in other places, but isn’t without risk. A bullpen lacking defined roles can quickly unravel, as Kansas City learned last season.
The Royals’ pen posted a 4.21 ERA and ranked 21st in the league over the first half of 2024 while juggling late-inning responsibilities. Once Lucas Erceg was locked in as the ninth-inning guy, the bullpen stabilized — improving to a 4.00 ERA, ranking 11th in WAR, and closing the season strong with a 2.77 ERA in the final month. That same group later powered an upset over the Orioles in the postseason. The takeaway? Defined roles build confidence — and lead to results.
Francona is taking the long view. There’s still time to find the right formula, but the Reds can’t linger in limbo forever. If Díaz doesn’t seize the job soon, someone else will have to step up and claim it.
Be the first to comment