The quarterback situation for the Indianapolis Colts remains uncertain, meaning Anthony Richardson might face competition for his starting job. Over the past two seasons, Richardson has held the starting role, but as he enters his third year, questions about his abilities make 2025 a pivotal season for his growth. He’ll need to prove himself to keep the starting position, and it won’t come easily.

During his Year-End Press Conference, Chris Ballard addressed the team’s quarterback situation, emphasizing the importance of competition. Ballard highlighted how competition drives players to improve, something Richardson desperately needs as a quarterback. With this in mind, the Colts could explore several potential candidates to challenge Richardson and, ideally, help elevate his performance.

Three Quarterback Candidates Who Could Compete with Anthony Richardson

Sam Darnold

The top free-agent quarterback heading into the 2025 season is 27-year-old veteran Sam Darnold. His 2024 campaign was remarkable, as he led the Minnesota Vikings to an impressive 14-win season before falling in the Wild Card round of the playoffs.

 

 

While many argue Darnold has earned a starting role in 2025, there are valid reasons for skepticism. His success in 2024 was bolstered by a strong supporting cast, including superstar receiver Justin Jefferson, a top-ten running back in Aaron Jones, and a solid defense.

The Indianapolis Colts could benefit from Darnold’s veteran leadership and game-management skills. Known for his calm demeanor, Darnold could bring stability to the team. However, whether the Colts should pursue such a high-profile quarterback remains uncertain. What the team needs in their quarterback room is someone who can challenge Anthony Richardson for the starting role, and Darnold fits that description.

Jameis Winston

Former number-one overall pick Jameis Winston is set to hit free agency again this offseason. After an inconsistent 2024 campaign, Winston is seeking stability and an opportunity to provide it in return. There’s no denying his ability to bring energy and vocal leadership to a locker room. However, his chances of being a full-time starter have diminished, largely due to his struggles with turnovers, including pick-sixes. While Winston likely wouldn’t pose a serious challenge to the starting quarterback role, he could serve as the competitive presence Richardson needs.

As a starter in 2024, Winston posted a 2-5 record, throwing for 2,121 yards and 13 touchdowns, but also recorded 12 interceptions and five fumbles. Despite these setbacks, he’s proven he can still win in the NFL. For the Colts, who remain uncertain about Richardson’s durability, adding a dependable backup capable of stepping in and securing wins could be crucial for their success in 2024.

Jimmy Garoppolo

Former two-time Super Bowl champion backup and Conference-winning starting quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo is set to become a free agent in 2025. Since leaving the San Francisco 49ers, Garoppolo has played for both the Raiders and the Rams. In 2024, he made a lone appearance in a Week 18 game against the Seattle Seahawks, where he demonstrated his ability to perform at a high level. In that game, Garoppolo threw for 334 yards on 27 completions, with two touchdowns and one interception. While the game held no playoff implications, it highlighted his strong understanding of the quarterback position—something Anthony Richardson is still developing.

If the Colts were to sign Garoppolo, the move would be similar to Jameis Winston’s situation. Garoppolo wouldn’t compete for the starting role but would serve as a mentor to Richardson and provide a dependable backup option. This could be crucial for the Colts, especially if Joe Flacco does not return.